Fat Bettys Pizza

Enjoy delectable white pizza, stromboli, wings, and grinders at Fat Bettys Pizza in Brookville, PA. Featuring arcade games, friendly staff, and a cozy atmosphere. Call +1 814-849-4925 for carryout!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Fat Bettys Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Fat Bettys Pizza
Fat Bettys Pizza
Fat Bettys Pizza
Fat Bettys Pizza

Fat Betty's Pizza stands as a vibrant gem nestled at 1 Evans St, Brookville, PA. This inviting pizzeria offers an experience that goes beyond mere dining. With a warm atmosphere and an enthusiastic staff, Fat Betty's wields its charm like a pizza cutter to a fresh pie. Visitors often praise the arcade games that bring a dash of fun amidst the savory aromas of baking strombolis and pizzas. Think about the comfort of sinking into a cozy booth while enjoying a delicious slice.

If you crave a casual dining experience filled with laughter, games, and fantastic food, Fat Betty's is the place to be. Cash is king here, ensuring a simple and swift transaction, so remember to bring some along to indulge in delightful culinary treats!

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

1 Evans St, Brookville, PA 15825, United States

Phone

+1 814-849-4925

About

The Culinary Story

Fat Bettys Pizza
Fat Bettys Pizza
Fat Bettys Pizza
Fat Bettys Pizza

Fat Betty's Pizza represents much more than just food. This lively spot captures the essence of Brookville's spirit, where local flavors intertwine with genuine hospitality. The restaurant specializes in stromboli, famed for its delightful house recipe that keeps customers returning for more. Each bite delivers a wonderful mix of ingredients stuffed into a perfectly baked crust. As you explore the menu, don’t miss out on the clam pizza or the vegetarian-friendly spinach and mushroom options, which add to the variety on offer.

The restaurant made its mark on the community, known for its cash-only policy which actually fosters connections—the regulars exchange stories while they wait their turn at the register. People often flock here not just to eat, but to enjoy camaraderie, creating bonds as strong as the cheese on their pizzas. An inviting staff works diligently to maintain the warm and lively atmosphere, ensuring each visit is a special occasion.

The homey décor features local art and memorabilia, enhancing the charm and connection to Brookville. The small space allows for just the right amount of buzz, making it easy to strike up conversations with fellow diners. Fat Betty’s isn’t just another pizza place; it’s a community hub where food, laughter, and relationships overlap—all while enjoying delicious meals made with love.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday12-7 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Fat Betty's Pizza boasts an impressive array of features that make it a standout spot. The menu hosts 12 mouthwatering items, including its renowned House Stromboli, which captures the hearts of old and new fans alike. The white pizza takes center stage, effortlessly combining a blend of flavors for a unique taste experience. Customers rave about the variety, including clam pizza and hearty grinders, ensuring that every palate finds its delight. The small dining area fosters a sense of community, turning meals into shared moments. Guests can also challenge themselves with arcade games that add a competitive twist to dining and make for an unforgettable outing. Whether dinings in or taking out, the experience remains intact, inviting everyone to relish every bite without any fuss.

Fat Bettys Pizza

Fat Betty's Pizza highlights an inviting exterior that beckons passersby with a familiar charm. The simplicity of the face-lifted building makes it approachable—expect bright signage and an entrance filled with the hints of pizza being baked. The outdoor vibe encourages relaxation, with patrons often chatting outside or savoring takeout on a nearby bench. The fun atmosphere spills out from within, where laughter and the sound of arcade machines create a buzz that’s difficult to resist.

As a place that embraces community interactions, it’s common to see families, friends, and even solitary diners finding joy over a plate of wings. Every visit feels like stopping by a friend’s house rather than just another meal out.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

The pizza taste great all the way from the crust to the cheese. It's definitely worth a try if you haven't had it.

J
Jake B.

Absolutely delicious! Our cross-country trip was made more interesting by stopping by this local eatery. We got stromboli and grinders and root beer floats. They've got an arcade that our little one dumped all our change into to get a local high score! This was such a nice change from fast food while traveling, and we hope to come back on our return trip!

L
LaNita M.

I got 2 large pizzas and garlic bread tonight. The kid working was nice. He makes a mean pizza. The food was pretty good for what it is. The large pizza is bigger than a large most places sell at a cheaper price. I should've tried their stromboli. I'm not from the area. So, I don't know if I'll ever go there again. But, today's visit was worth mentioning.

J
John A.

1st time ordering from Fat Betty's and I would highly recommend this place!!! Can honestly say it's probably the best pizza in town!!

K
Kristen S.

When I tell you the food was delicious it really was! Jay can throw down in that kitchen. Everything was absolutely delicious

M
Megan L.

Give this place a real chance if you haven't ate here yet. It has some pretty good food for very fair prices. Had the Italian grinder, white pizza and garlic sticks all were pretty good especially the grinder and sticks. Nice little dining room also with an old pizza/arcade vibe. It is cash only which had kept me away from stopping before, but it was worth it and will be back again.

A
Adam N.